Butterfinger

Butterfinger

Ranking: 19
Annual sales: $123.9 million
Who makes it: Nestlé

Curtiss Candy, the Chicago-based maker of Baby Ruth, staged a contest to name its new candy bar in 1923. A Chicago man, who described himself as something of a klutz, suggested Butterfinger. The candy, with its orange peanut-flavored center, was acquired by Nestlé in 1990.