No. 34: Muttontown, N.Y.

No. 34: Muttontown, N.Y.

New York MSA: Nassau County
Median home sale price: $1,448,019
Price change YOY: -0.3%
Population: 3,413
Median household income: $184,386

Surrounded by many other expensive towns in Long Island and only 25 minutes from Manhattan, Muttontown is known for its 550-acre nature preserve, the largest on Long Island.